That All May Have Life in Fullness - Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) 216th General Assembly; Richmond, Virginia - June 26 - July 3, 2004 PC(USA) Seal
 
 
             
  GA04008          
     
 

'Tear down this wall'

Palestinians urge U.S. Christians to do more than just talk

 
     
  by Alexa Smith  
             
 

RICHMOND - Christian leaders in Palestine are urging mainline U.S. churches to talk less and do more.

Education is fine, they say, but action must follow.

They want concrete strategies that have a real impact on Palestinian life - such as helping émigrés return home and boycotting U.S. companies that invest in Israel's illegal settlements.

"To have statements is not enough," says the Rev. Mitri Raheb, a Lutheran pastor from Bethlehem. "They might be good for discussions within churches . but they're not much help to us on the ground."

  The Rev. Mitri Raheb speaks from Bethlehem. Photo by Alexa Smith.
The Rev. Mitri Raheb speaks from Bethlehem. Photo by Alexa Smith
 
             
 

That's part of the message Raheb will deliver Thursday morning when he is the featured speaker at the Worldwide Ministries Division breakfast at the Marriott Hotel here.

Israeli bulldozers are circling Bethlehem with a 40-foot wall that will threatens to strangle the city of 150,000 residents, trapping Palestinian civilians inside, cutting them off from jobs, families and medical care.

"Governments don't care if you issue a statement," Raheb says. "The problem is: Churches didn't develop an action plan to be implemented here on the ground."

Raheb said he wishes U.S. and Palestinian church leaders would develop a 10-year plan for Palestine, addressing the questions: "What are the needs? What is required? And where can we make a difference now?"

Strategizing on Palestine has been slow in the churches - there and here.

"You're fighting a war on about three fronts," says the Rev. Eileen Lindner, a Presbyterian who is the associate general secretary of the National Council of Churches of Christ.

Lindner says it is harder for U.S. churches to work strategically in the Middle East because Christian aid agencies have no infrastructure there, as they do in Europe and South Africa.

She says church people fear being labeled anti-Semitic and upsetting ecumenical relationships if they criticize Israel. Plus, they have to fight U.S. policy in a "head-knocking way."

 
             
 

"They're not afraid of being called anti-Palestinian," Bishop Riah Abu-Assal, the Episcopalian Bishop of Jerusalem, says in a telephone interview - and who is plainly frustrated by the anxiety. "(Speaking out) is not anti-Semitic. It's not anti-Jewish. It is anti-Israel-government policy."

Abu-Assal proposed during a recent General Assembly of the World

  Bethlehem—a small city—is being hemmed in by settlements, seen at the top of the hill, and by the wall. Photo by Alexa Smith.
Bethlehem-a small city-is being hemmed in by settlements, seen at the top of the hill, and by the wall.  Photo by Alexa Smith
 
 

Council of Churches that it launch a boycott of corporations that profit from businesses in Israel's illegal settlements. "If you impact the goods produced in the settlements," he told the WCC delegates, "it will put an end to business there."

He says his remarks drew applause - but no action.

The Rev. Victor Makari, the PC(USA)'s liaison to the Middle East, has empathy for Abu-Assal's bind. He says the PC(USA) has worked hard for decades to educate its members about the realities of Israeli policy and about life in Palestine.

"Such cumulative constituency education has helped changed the attitude in our churches," he says.

 
             
 

The PC(USA)'s strategy so far has been education and "accompaniment" - travel to Palestine to support the Christians there and to learn about the situation on the ground.

The denomination conducts travel/study seminars and produces study materials. Missonary Douglas Dicks works full-time in Jerusalem setting up trips for Presbyterians. Two former missionaries, Elizabeth and Marthame Saunders, will work in the Presbyterian Center in 2005 to help deepen Presbyterians' understanding of Palestinian life.

The denomination also has also helped meet the financial needs of historic partners, such as a Christian hospital in war-torn Gaza.

  Bishop Riah Abu-Assal speaks from his Jerusalem office. Photo by David P. Young.
Bishop Riah Abu-Assal speaks from his Jerusalem office. Photo by David P. Young
 
             
 

The problem now, Makari says, is that, with the peace process stalled for the past four years, "things are deteriorating with such rapidity" that it is hard to tell what strategy will be most effective.

The Palestinian economy has ground to a standstill. Many families are living on less than $2 a day, according to the United Nations. And the wall is under construction now on the outskirts of Jerusalem.

Abu-Assal is proposing that U.S. churches help émigré Palestinians return home - just as the Israelis help Jews establish themselves in Israel. "We need to do exactly what the Jews do . Pay for their travel. Give them (money) to begin over. Provide them housing. Try to find them a job. I think we can do the same. But we cannot do it alone."

Abu-Assal says the Episcopal Diocese owns vacant property, but doesn't have money to build on it. He envisions shelter not only for émigrés, but for Palestinians who would otherwise be cut off from Jerusalem by the wall.

"What do we need here?" he says. "We need to bring back those who've emigrated. Otherwise, I fear for the Christian presence in the area."

Ann Hafften, coordinator of Middle East Networks for the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America (ELCA),understands that some Lutherans are content to work within the church's system, but others need to engage issues in less traditional ways. "We have a traditional strategy. But then, we're a traditional church," she says.

She says some individual Lutherans have joined secular groups like one in Texas that is trying to launch a boycott of Caterpillar tractors, the U.S.-made equipment the Israeli army uses to demolish Palestinian homes on the West Bank and in the Gaza Strip.

The Lutheran Bishop of Jerusalem, Munib Younan, told the Presbyterian News Service that he'd also like to see housing for Palestinians built on Lutheran-owned property on the Mount of Olives in Jerusalem.

Palestinian leaders often liken the situation in Palestine to that in South Africa under apartheid. "The situation here is worse than in South Africa," Abu-Assal says, yet the international church equivocates instead of acting.

Raheb, who was a book tour in the United States when former President Ronald Reagan died, says:

"I'd like to hear the church telling Bush and Sharon, 'Tear down this wall. Especially now. The moment of truth has come. I'd like for churches to speak very clearly about the wall, and the apartheid system."

 
             
PC(USA) Home (Link)
     
   
 

Home

 
   
 

Worship & Bible Study

 
   
 

News

 
   
 

Audio and Video

 
   
  Business Before
the Assembly
 
   
 

Moderator

 
   
 

Resources

 
   
  Photos  
   
  About General Assembly  
   
     
  Click here to visit the Committee on Local Arrangements Web site.  
     
  Click here for special information for Commissioners and Advisory Delegates.  
     

 

 

   
  For more information, contact PresbyTel at (800) 872-3283, or click here to send an email.  
     
  Link to Top of Page  
 
Contact PC(USA) (link)