Mission Connections PC (USA) Seal PC(USA) logo (link to home)
 
 
             
  A letter from Mark Hare in Haiti  
             
 

August 23, 2004

Hey Friend,

In May, tragedy struck again in Haiti. So common it must seem normal. “Haiti,” when you see it in the news, seems always to be linked to tragedy. Political tragedies, “natural” disaster tragedies, food-scarcity tragedies.

Flooding in southern Haiti in May took many lives, possibly as many as 3,000 in south central Haiti. Thousands more have been affected, many families left without shelter, their animals and crops swept away. Analysis in the news articles I’ve read blames deforestation on the tragedy. That is not a difficult conclusion to draw. Haiti is infamous for its lack of forest cover. While it’s true that deforestation did nothing to help the situation, excessive rainfall in any region with a hilly or mountainous topography can result in flooding. In my hometown, Amesville, Ohio, four or five inches of rainfall fell in less than 24 hours in 1998 and washed away a significant portion of our small village, destroying about a quarter of the houses along with our one restaurant and our convenience store. Clear-cutting on the forested hillsides around our town may or may not have affected the flooding, but no one suggested that deforestation was the main cause. An engineer who has worked in the area around Mapou told me that the hardest-hit area in Haiti was above a bottleneck through which all of the waters from miles around must pass on their way to the sea.

 
             
  Photograph of a deforested hillside in Haiti.
A deforested hillside in Haiti's central plateau. Deforestation is a complex problem. MPP works to change the situation by looking at the technical issues and by addressing the root causes.
  My point isn’t to discount the importance of deforestation in Haiti. On the contrary, the dream of Haiti restored in all of its forested glory is one of the drives for my presence here. I was reminded of that a couple of weeks ago when I was working with most of the other members of MPP’s technical team (MPP stands for Farmer’s Movement of Papaye) filling in a compost pit with tree leaves, ashes, peanut husks, and horse, cow and donkey manure.  
             
 

Mulaire (pronounced “Mee-lair”) asked me why I studied forestry as opposed to agriculture, which is closer to my current area of work. I told him about my father and all the trees we planted in our backyard when I was young. He was suitably impressed, I think, although I didn’t tell him that our main motivation at the time was to avoid having much grass to mow. My motivation for seeing trees grow has changed and deepened—although weed control is in fact one of the many benefits that trees can provide in a well-integrated agricultural system. I feel a fundamental joy when I see a barren area we have planted to trees become an explosion of green; the seed of that joy was planted along with the seedlings 30 some years ago.

It is because reforestation is so important to me that I can’t bear to plant a tree if it doesn’t meet the needs and priorities of the people who control that tree’s fate. Deforestation in Haiti is not and never has been a random event, nor is it a malicious attack on Mother Nature. In most cases, it’s a logical and reasonable response to a series of perverse circumstances created by policies outside the control of the local population. Understanding the conditions that result in an unbalanced and destructive use of tree resources is essential, because our job is not just to grow and plant trees; it is to help create conditions where deforestation is reversed, where mountains that have been the cause of a people’s destruction again become the source of life and love and laughter.

One example of the complexity of deforestation in Haiti is charcoal. Charcoal production, one of the main causes of deforestation, is also one of the only reliable sources of income in many rural areas. Income from charcoal helps Haiti’s rural population pay for health and education, and it provides cash to buy food when climatic instability results in yet another crop loss. Climatic instability, in turn, is enhanced by deforestation. This downward spiral of misery and resource destruction is rooted in Haiti’s history as a country manipulated and exploited by the United States and European countries, and by the exploitation of rural producers by the urban wealthy.

In recent years, the destructive spiral in Haiti and other underdeveloped nations has been accelerated by international policies, notably those of the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund. These “structural adjustment” plans are referred to as “globalization,” and people I work with refer to them as “The Plan of Death.” One of the most deadly elements is opening up Haiti to highly subsidized agricultural products, mostly from the United States but also from Europe and Asia. These products, such as rice and corn, are sold for less than production cost, driving down local prices and forcing farmers to either abandon their land and move to the cities or to focus on the few reliable sources of income, such as charcoal.

Dealing with the complexity of problems in Haiti’s rural countryside requires an integrated system of techniques that deal with the multiple levels of people’s needs and get at the roots of the problems. MPP, the Papaye Farmer’s Movement, the organization with which I work, is made up of autonomous local community groups in Haiti’s central plateau. MPP responds to the peoples most urgent needs while helping to educate and inform them. One magnificent result of this interactive relationship is a fully integrated, wide-ranging and yet intensive approach that addresses both the results of poverty and its underlying causes. MPP brings groups together to define and address the political conditions that affect their livelihoods, while at the same time supporting agricultural and economic projects that help farmers address their urgent needs for food and money.

Many blessings.

Mark

The 2004 Mission Yearbook for Prayer & Study, p. 140

 
             
PC(USA) Home (Link)
     
   
  Home  
   
  Mission Speakers  
   
  Mission Workers  
   
  Letters from Young Adult Volunteers  
   
  Photo Albums  
   
  Archives  
   
  Frequently Asked Questions  
   
 
  RSS icon
 
   
     
  show your support  
     
   
     
   
     
     
  For more information contact Peter Kemmerle (888) 728-7228 x5612, Anne Blair (888) 728-7228 x5373, or Carol Somplatsky-Jarman (888) 728-7228 x5628 - Or write to: 100 Witherspoon Street, Louisville, KY, 40202  
     
  Link to Top of Page  
 
Contact PC (USA) (link)