Mission Connections PC (USA) Seal PC(USA) logo (link to home)
 
 
             
  A letter from Arch Woodruff and Linnis Cook in Brazil  
             
 

November 8, 2002

Brazil Has a New President

As you may know, the voters of Brazil have just elected a new president of the Republic. His name is José Inácio da Silva, and his nickname is Lula. Having lived in Brazil for 15 years, going on 16, I am writing my impressions for anyone who may be wondering what kind of man Lula is.

When Linnis and I arrived in Brazil in March of 1987, Lula was one of the first public figures of whom we became aware. He was the leader of the Workers Party (PT) and had recently led an historic strike of the Metalworkers' Union against the Brazilian auto industry. The PT itself was rather new. I perceived Lula then as a labor leader with factory-gate manners. He didn't mince words about issues: "There is a war going on against the poor," he said. Inflation was 20 percent per month and rising, and Lula had strong words (virtually untranslatable) about what this was doing to peoples' salaries.

 
             
 

"When it comes to his way of talking about people, or not talking about them, Lula may have the cleanest mouth in Brazil."

  But there were several things that made Lula different. One was that, however strongly he spoke about the issues, he never seemed to make a personal attack on anybody. That is remarkable in Brazil, where politicians never seem to tire of lambasting each other. It can start with "Your Excellency is a person without shame" and go from there. When it comes to his way of talking about people, or not talking about them, Lula may have the cleanest mouth in Brazil.  
             
 

That does not make him a cultivated speaker of his own language. He had very few years of schooling before he went to work as a laborer, and he comes from the Northeast of Brazil, a region some people think of as backward. Wags asked, "What is it that Marx, Engels and Lula have in common?" The intended answer: "Not a one of them speaks Portuguese." People used to question Lula's relative lack of formal schooling. However, he has spent the last 15+ years preparing himself for the kinds of responsibility which now fall upon him. But while the signs of his origin may always be upon his tongue, there is very little that is backward about this man.

Back then Lula was already dialoguing with those who would normally oppose him, accepting a speaking engagement at the War College (Escola Superior de Guerra, or ESG, a redoubt of hardline military officers). The dialoguing has never stopped, and Lula has gotten a great deal smoother.

Another thing that was striking about Lula was that he was a master at holding his own party together. The PT is really a coalition, made up of a variety of "tendencies." Some of the tendencies are rather sectarian, being made up of true believers in one or another political doctrine; others are closer to the Catholic Church. Lula's "tendency" within the party is called the "articulation," which may tell you something. They could easily go flying off in different directions. It was striking that Lula could hold his party together, while the president of the Republic who was then in power was unable to hold his cabinet together.

In 1990, Lula was the PT's candidate for President and almost won. In the runoff election, after the field had been narrowed down to two candidates, Lula crept up from behind until he and Fernando Collor de Mello were neck-and-neck. Then Mr. Collor played dirty, and put Lula's ex-girlfriend on TV to say what she thought of him. Then Collor won by a narrow margin, and went on to a presidency that would end in impeachment. In 1994 and 1998 Lula tried again, and the future seemed to be well-defined: the PT would always choose Lula as its presidential candidate, and Lula would always lose.

In 2002 Lula came out and told his party he was tired of losing. Then he started to pursue alliances outside his party on a scale never attempted by that party before. Some of the alliances made his party swallow hard. As a strategy for getting elected, it worked. It is clear that many people voted for Lula for President who did not vote for his party in other races.

The U.S. ambassador, Donna Hrinak, knows the PT well and has had dialogue with it before. She has told the press she expects negotiations to be difficult, which is doubtless putting it mildly. She is clearly different from the in-your-face diplomats who have made waves in Venezuela and Bolivia. One in-your-face type made a strong statement about how Brazil had better join ALCA (Free Trade Area of the Americas, FTAA in English), to which Lula replied: "I am not going to answer the deputy of the deputy of the deputy (in Portuguese: o sub do sub do sub); when I am President I will talk about this with Bush himself." Those are the words of an experienced negotiator.

On matters of economic expertise, Lula will have access to some pretty good minds. One of the people available to him will be an economist, Aloísio Mercadante, who spoke to a visiting group of Presbyterians here in São Paulo not too long ago.

One more quote from Lula: "The PT put me in office, but I am going to be everybody's president." I think he means that. When PT people have been mayors, they have tended that way.

His natural adversaries are being surprisingly good losers, and the climate is one of celebration of democracy. For now, the sense is that your party might have lost, but the country won.

Archibald M. Woodruff
Mission Co-Worker
Brazil

The 2002 Mission Yearbook for Prayer & Study, p. 258

 
             
PC(USA) Home (Link)
     
   
  Home  
   
  Mission Speakers  
   
  Mission Workers  
   
  Letters from Young Adult Volunteers  
   
  Photo Albums  
   
  Archives  
   
 
  RSS icon
 
   
     
  show your support  
     
   
     
     
  For more information contact Peter Kemmerle (888) 728-7228 x5612, Anne Blair (888) 728-7228 x5373, or Carol Somplatsky-Jarman (888) 728-7228 x5628 - Or write to: 100 Witherspoon Street, Louisville, KY, 40202  
     
  Link to Top of Page  
 
Contact PC (USA) (link)