PC NEWS - Presbyterian News Service
PC (USA) Seal PC(USA) Homepage
 
 
             
 

04090
February 19, 2004

Baptist leaders, criticizing theology, vote to leave world alliance

99-year relationship coming to an end

by Adelle M. Banks
Religion News Service

 
             
  WASHINGTON — The Executive Committee of the Southern Baptist Convention voted overwhelmingly Feb. 17 to recommend that the denomination withdraw its membership and funding from the Baptist World Alliance.

A report from a study committee said the time has come “to politely withdraw from an organization that, at least for us, no longer efficiently communicates to the unsaved a crystal clear gospel message that our Lord Jesus Christ is solely sufficient for salvation.”

The Rev. Denton Lotz, general secretary of the Falls Church, VA-based alliance, said the 62-10 vote saddened his organization and the description of its biblical stance was “a misrepresentation of the truth.”

The Executive Committee’s recommendation will be considered at the annual meeting of the denomination in June. If approved, an official 99-year-old relationship between the two Baptist bodies would come to an end Oct. 1.

“It’s a schism and a schism against love,” said Lotz.

The move would unlock the longtime link between the nation’s largest Protestant denomination and 210 other Baptist conventions across the globe.

Last June, Southern Baptists voted to reduce annual funding of the alliance from $425,000 to $300,000. Lotz said “thousands of individuals and churches are already making up the difference.” His organization, with a $1.6 million budget, has cut expenses but he remains confident about its future.

“It’s not a monetary question,” Lotz said. “It’s a question of fellowship around the world.”

In a statement, Bill Merrell, the committee’s vice president for convention relations, acknowledged the instrumental role the denomination had in the formation of the alliance.

“However, in recent years, it has become evident that key leaders and influences within the BWA differ in essential areas that we can no longer ignore,” he said.

The committee action was taken after a report in December made similar recommendations. That report cited the alliance’s “leftward drift” and said its participants “openly oppose many of our most cherished beliefs.”

Lotz said the latest language approved by the committee’s vote was “shocking” and an insult to his association, which he said affirms a “classic definition of orthodoxy,” from the Incarnation to the Second Coming of Jesus.

Some Southern Baptist leaders objected when the alliance accepted the moderate Cooperative Baptist Fellowship as a member last year, but the study committee’s report said that was not the sole cause for the recommended departure.

“One soaked by a rain need not blame the last raindrop,” the report reads.

The Tuesday vote included an additional request that the study committee meet with alliance representatives before May.

“They don’t anticipate a change but they do want to have an opportunity to meet with the BWA leaders one more time before the convention,” said John Revell, a spokesman for the Executive Committee.

Lotz said BWA officials proposed a “reconciliation meeting” in a January letter.

“We want to be reconciled,” he said. “We don’t want them to leave.”

While the vote had been expected, objecting arguments were heard before and during the Executive Committee meeting. U.S. congregations and Baptist bodies overseas had sent pleas to the committee to work out its differences with the alliance.

Dr. Bob Casey, a retired physician from Gainesville, FL, spent the week before the meeting fasting and doing a “prayer walk” around the offices of the Executive Committee in Nashville. He delivered an opposing resolution from his church, which permits its members to support mission causes of either the Southern Baptist Convention or the Cooperative Baptist Fellowship.

During the meeting, representatives of the Woman’s Missionary Union, a denominational auxiliary, and a committee member from Pennsylvania voiced views against the recommendation.

The Baptist Convention of Pennsylvania/South Jersey wrote in a resolution that it urged Baptists worldwide “to pray fervently for God to ... bring reconciliation between the BWA and the SBC for a unified witness to a world in need of Christ.”

The approved recommendation calls for the funds currently sent to the alliance to be used to enhance relationships with “conservative evangelical Christians” across the globe.

“If we can multiply the harvest by reapplying the funding, there is no true Christian who should take issue,” the report concluded.

 
             

PC(USA) Home (Link)
PC(USA) Search (link)

     
  subnavigation divider  
   
 
subnavigation divider
 
   
 
subnavigation divider
 
   
 
subnavigation divider
 
   
 
subnavigation divider
 
   
 
subnavigation divider
 
   
  subnavigation divider  
   
  subnavigation divider  
     
  GA216 - The 2004 Presbyterian General Assembly - News  
     
  Click here to download the news!  
     
  PC NEWS - PC(USA) - photo thoughts  

 

     
 
For more information contact the Presbyterian News Service - 100 Witherspoon Street - Louisville, KY - 40222 - Call (888) 728-7228 x5540 - Fax (502) 569-8073
 
     
  Link to Top of Page  
 
Contact PC(USA)
Copyright © 2001-2004 Presbyterian Church (USA). All Rights Reserved