Presbyterians Today: Making the church's witness relevant to today's Presbyterians
PC(USA) Seal
 
 
             
  PT Media Picks: Films and Videos  
             
 

Love trumps diplomacy

The Girl in the Cafe

(DVD HBO Films; 100 minutes; $26.98)

 
             
 

He's a distinguished older British diplomat working at the G-8 Summit on issues of world poverty. She's a quiet, charming young ex-con he encounters in a cafe. Their love story, now available on DVD from HBO Films, goes beyond the usual boy-meets-girl genre to deliver a powerful message about the need for global economic justice.

  Photo: Man and woman talk across a table
A life-changing encounter. Photo by Joss Barrett
 
             
 

Gina, the girl of the title, falls in love — not only with Lawrence, who is astounded that any woman so young and beautiful is interested in him, but also with his humanitarian mission. When she accompanies him to G-8 events, she is radically outspoken, embarrassing him and helping him see his work with new eyes. As Lawrence gets to know her, and hears her story of poverty and loss, his passion for his mission is renewed.

The climax of the file is Gina's delivery of what might be the best speech ever, by politician or lay person, making the case for going "the extra mile" to end world poverty. She delivers it at an official banquet, putting Lawrence's job at risk and getting herself tossed out by security. But in the end, her commitment to "speaking truth to power" wins the day.

If the love story doesn't thrill you, the story of a brave young woman speaking out for starving children and mothers worldwide certainly will.

Teresa Blythe

 
             
   
 

Mature beyond her years

The Education of Shelby Knox

(DVD; Incite Pictures, 2005)

 
             
 

Any pastor or educator in a mainline church would love to have a Shelby Knox in the congregation. Shelby, as depicted in Rose Rosenblatt and Marion Lipschutz's well-made documentary, is the epitome of the teenager capable of thinking for herself and defending her reasoned faith against assault by others, even adults in positions of authority.

The film follows Shelby's development from her sophomore year in high school through her graduation — years that prove to be far more eventful for her than for the typical teenager who goes along with the crowd.

Shelby is in a youth group at a Southern Baptist Church in Lubbock, Texas, where she joins her peers in a public ceremony of pledging chastity. But she knows that the rates of teen pregnancy and sexually transmitted diseases in Lubbock are among the highest in America; and she knows that many of her friends who don't attend church are sexually active, and often pay a high price for their transgressions.

  Photo: teenage girl with her parents
Shelby Knox with her parents, Paula and Danny Knox, outside their home in Lubbock, Texas. Photo by Robert Maass
 
             
 

Believing that saying "No" is not enough, she joins a student group advocating sex education and the distribution of condoms — which her youth pastor opposes and her parents fret about. The teenager soon learns about the devious politics that roil the school board and the superintendent's office — the super refuses to meet with the sex-ed student group — and is dismayed when one of her peers tries to use the group for his own self-aggrandizement.

By the time she's a high school senior, Shelby has left the student group far behind, become convinced that a gay students' group merits her support, and come to an understanding with her conservative parents — that they will love each other, but disagree on some basic issues. She is lucky to have parents who, despite their dismay over her abandonment of their conservative principles (she even becomes a Democrat), love and respect her enough to give her the freedom to choose her own way.

The scenes showing Shelby and her youth pastor disagreeing over sex education and gay rights will be of special interest to pastors and church educators. This, in fact, would be a great film to show to a group of parents and youth to spark discussion, not just of the social issues addressed in the film, but of ways teens and parents can love and respect each other and get along despite their differences.

The Education of Shelby Knox was first seen at the Sundance Film Festival in 2005. It was later aired on PBS's "Point of View" series, and is now available on DVD. For sales and rental information, call Incite Pictures at (212) 216-9315, or email Incite at info@incite-pictures.com.

Edward McNulty

 
             
   
  All the way to the cross
Bonhoeffer

Documentary directed by Martin Doblmeier (DVD, 90 minutes; to be shown on PBS on Feb. 6, 2006)

 
             
  Bonhoeffer
Photo credit: Courtesy First Run Features
  German theologian and martyr Deitrich Bonhoeffer was executed by the dying Nazi regime in 1945, yet his influence remains strong to this day, as Martin Doblmeier's powerful documentary shows. This chronicle of Bonhoeffer's life includes interviews with his students, relatives, and such notable church leaders as Archbishop Desmond Tutu, the latter testifying that Bonhoeffer's writings and struggle against Nazism were inspirations for his own struggle against apartheid. Especially interesting is a segment on Bonhoeffer's first visit to America, as a student fellow at Union Theological Seminary in New York, where he was influenced by the activist theology of Reinhold Niebuhr. Bonhoeffer came to love Negro spirituals and attended Harlem's Abyssinian Baptist Church, then served by Rev. Adam Clayton Powell Sr. Niebuhr and Powell both widened Bonhoeffer's perspective on the role of the church in society.  
             
 

After returning to Germany, Bonhoeffer was part of the minority of Germans who resisted Adolf Hitler and spoke out on behalf of persecuted Jews. He was able to travel to various countries, where he passed on information proving that, despite Hitler's denials, Jews and others who resisted Nazi policy were being terrorized, abused and murdered.

The film makes good use of archival films and photographs from the Nazi era — even clips from home movies, including one that shows Bonhoeffer playing ball with his family. The most chilling sequence shows Hitler shaking hands with a high-ranking clergyman as another minister and a clutch of Nazi officers raise their arms in salute. Bonhoeffer speaks for himself a number of times (his words read by the actor Klaus Maria Brandauer).

At a time when conservatives and liberals alike use quotations from Bonhoeffer to bolster their positions on controversial topics, and church's role in society is still being debated, this film reminds us that the mark of faithfulness is willingness to follow Christ all the way to the cross, as Bonhoeffer certainly did. The DVD includes an interview with the director, additional archival photos, and samples of Bonhoeffer's writings, making it an excellent resource for a four- to six-session study in a church school class or adult group. This is a film every Christian should see!

Edward McNulty

More information on Bonhoeffer and this DVD is to be made available on the PBS Web site, which already has information on the dramatic biopic, Bonhoeffer, Agent of Grace (also available on DVD), a good companion to Doblmeier's film.

 
             
 
   
             
PC(USA) Home (Link)
     
   
   
   
  Subscribe  
   
  Advertising  
   
  Shop the Store  
   
  About Presbyterians Today  
   
   
   
     
  Order the 2008 Advent Calendar.  
     
   
     
  Graphic: For more information contact Presbyterians Today, 100 Witherspoon Street, Louisville, KY 40202, (888) 728-7228, x5637 or FAX (502) 569-8632, or send email. Send email to Presbyterians Today  
     
  Link to Top of Page  
 
Contact PC(USA) (Link)