Refugee Women and Children Need
Protection
By Elenora Giddings Ivory
The percentage of civilians killed and wounded as a result
of hostilities has risen from five percent of all casualties
at the turn of the 19th century to 65 percent during World
War II and to 90 percent in more recent hostilities. Women
and children comprise the majority of civilian deaths and the
majority of all refugees. In the last decade, more than 2,000,000
children have been killed during wars, while more than 4,000,000
have survived physical mutilation, and more than 1,000,000
have been orphaned or separated from their families as a result
of war.
In many conflicts, soldiers have destroyed food supplies,
stolen donated food intended for women and children, and blocked
human- itarian aid. In 2003, around 300,000 children were pressed
into military operations, including many girls forced to work
as combatants, cooks, spies, or sexual slaves for soldiers.
The use of rape is a common tactic in modern war. The international
community has a duty to take preventive action to improve preparedness
and reduce the vulnerability of women and children to abuse
and exploitation.
Early Action Systems
U.S-appointed coordinators during times of emergencies should
maintain a data base on occurrences of gender-based violence
or exploitation of children and develop a data base on the
early signs that indicate a likelihood that gender-based
abuse of children will occur during a humanitarian emergency.
This information should be updated regularly, of countries
or regions where there is an increased risk of gender-based
violence against children. This information would improve
the preparedness of the U.S. Government, U.S. Embassies and
organizations to respond to such an emergency.
Security Concerns
Almost one-half of the world’s 37,500,000 refugees and
internally displaced persons are children. Food rations in
camps for refugees and internally displaced persons are often
limited and unpredictable, and vulnerable women rarely have
opportunities to generate income or products to barter for
additional food and other supplies.
Refugee women and girls face threats because of power inequities,
including being forced to exchange sex for food and humanitarian
supplies, and being at increased risk of rape and gender-based
violence due to the poor security in refugee camps. An investigation
into sexual exploitation of refugees by aid workers in West
Africa found many factors that contribute to the exploitation
and abuse of women and children, including:
- Few women working
in key positions in refugee relief efforts;
- Insufficient international
staff presence in the camps;
- Isolation and lack of separate
and distinctly placed sanitary facilities for men and women;
- Incomplete
rations and delayed delivery of supplies to refugees;
- Lack
of punishment for perpetrators, including adult refugees,
of sexual crimes against children.
Refugees and internally displaced persons living outside of
camps experience problems—vulnerability to harassment,
abuse, and exploitation by landlords and employers—with
little legal recourse, and constant threat of detention, imprisonment,
and deportation. Existing NGO and international agency policies,
procedures, training programs, and accountability mechanisms
have not protected women and children from abuse, provided
adequate assistance to survivors, or disciplined offenders
and achieved justice.
The limited presence of protection officers and other trained
managerial staff of the U.N. High Commissioner for Refugees
in camps, especially at night, exacerbates the vulnerability
of women and children to abuse by, specifically, fellow camp
residents and nearby local residents. Humanitarian agencies
have failed to make women and children aware of their rights
to protection and aid, to give them access to effective channels
of redress, and to make humanitarian workers aware of their
duty to respect these rights and provide aid.
Codes of Conduct
None of the funds made available by the Department of State
through the Migration and Refugee Assistance account or the
Emergency Refugee and Migration Assistance account may be
provided to an organization that has failed to adopt a code
of conduct on the protection of beneficiaries of humanitarian
assistance that incorporates the six core principles recommended
by the Inter-Agency Standing Committee:
(1) Sexual exploitation and abuse by humanitarian workers constitute
acts of gross misconduct and are therefore grounds for termination
of employment. (2) Sexual activity with persons under the age
of 18 years is prohibited regardless of the age of majority
or age of consent locally. Mistaken belief regarding the age
of a child is not a defense. (3) Exchange of money, employment,
goods, or services for sex, including sexual favors or other
forms of humiliating, degrading, or exploitative behavior,
is prohibited. (4) Sexual relationships between the providers
and beneficiaries of humanitarian assistance are strongly discouraged
since they are based on inherently unequal power dynamics.
Such relationships undermine the credibility and integrity
of humanitarian work. (5) Whenever a humanitarian assistance
worker develops concerns or suspicions about sexual abuse or
exploitation by a fellow worker, the worker must report such
concerns through established agency reporting mechanisms. (6)
Humanitarian assistance agencies are obliged to create and
maintain an environment that prevents sexual exploitation and
abuse and promotes the implementation of their code of conduct.
Managers at all levels have particular responsibilities to
support and develop systems that maintain this environment.
Practices in the Camps
All agencies, including multilateral and nongovernmental agencies,
that implement U.S. humanitarian assistance programs should
conduct a thorough review of their administrative, management,
and employment practices in refugee and displaced persons
camps, and:
(1) Significantly increase the number of women involved in
the distribution of food and supplies;
(2) Expand opportunities for women to generate legitimate income
in the camps, including through employment;
(3) Educate providers and beneficiaries of humanitarian assistance
about the seriousness of gender-based exploitation of children;
(4) Improve expatriate supervision and monitoring of daily
operations in the camps;
(5) Improve the design and logistics of camps to create a safer
environment for women and children;
(6) Keep formal and detailed records, including photographs,
of locally hired staff, and ensure that they are adequately
paid and trained;
(7) Provide training for humanitarian workers on their obligations
under a code of conduct;
(8) Develop systems of accountability to deter and punish gender-based
violence, exploitation of children, and other protection violations;
and
(9) Ensure that applicants for jobs in camps are screened to
prevent individuals who may have been involved in protection
violations from being hired by authorities.
Health Services
Complex humanitarian emergencies result in risks for women
and girls. Refugee and displaced women face heightened risks
of developing complications during pregnancy, suffering a
miscarriage, dying, being injured during childbirth, becoming
infected with HIV or another sexually transmitted infection,
or suffering from posttraumatic stress disorder. Despite
the heightened risks during an emergency, women’s needs
for specialized health services are often overlooked by donors
and relief organizations, which are focused on providing
food, water, and shelter. Priority activities and emergency supplies designed to address
life-threatening women’s health problems during a complex
humanitarian emergency are often not implemented or made available
in the early days and weeks of an emergency, the period when
such activities and supplies are most needed and effective.
The appointed coordinator of such emergencies shall seek to
ensure that organizations funded by the U.S. respond to the
specific health needs of women affected by the emergency; and
identify an organization or individual to facilitate the coordination
of the activities needed to respond to the health needs of
women as soon as possible.
The Women and Children in Conflict Protection Act of 2003 (S
1001) has been introduced by Sen. Biden (D-DE). It asserts
that:
(1) The nature of war has changed dramatically in recent decades,
putting women and children at greater risk of death, disease,
displacement, and exploitation.
(2) Civilians, particularly women and children, account for
the vast majority of those adversely affected by complex humanitarian
emergencies, including as refugees and internally displaced
persons, and increasingly are targeted by combatants and armed
elements for murder, abduction, forced military conscription,
involuntary servitude, displacement, sexual abuse and slavery,
mutilation, and loss of freedom.
(3) Traditionally, humanitarian response has focused on providing
food, medical care, and shelter needs, while placing less emphasis
on the safety and security of those affected by humanitarian
emergency.
(4) Few well-coordinated efforts exist to prevent and respond
to violence against women and children when they are refugees
or internally displaced persons.
(5) While the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees
and the Department of State are charged with protecting refugees,
there is no United States Government agency or international
body with a clear mandate to protect internally displaced persons
and those at risk of displacement as a result of a complex
humanitarian emergency.
(6) There is a substantial need for the protection of women
and children to be given a high priority during all complex
humanitarian emergencies.
S 1001 seeks to ensure that the U.S. Government has adequate
capabilities to support programs to provide for the protection
of women and children affected by a complex humanitarian emergency.
The bill states that this goal can be accomplished by building
the capacities of U.S. Government agencies, multilateral institutions,
international nongovernmental organizations, local nongovernmental
organizations, and local communities to prevent and respond
effectively to gender-based violence and exploitation of children
that occur during a complex humanitarian emergency. The bill
calls for increased funding as well as improved procedures
for the protection of women and children who are internally
displaced, made refugees, or otherwise affected by a complex
humanitarian emergency. (Excerpted from S 1001. Go to http://thomas.loc.gov)
Suggested Action
Contact your Senator by mail, phone or email to express your
concern for the plight of refugees around the world. Ask that
special attention be given to women and children because they
are often the victims during times of war.
The Honorable————
United States Senate
Washington, D.C. 20510
CALL the Capitol Switch board at (202) 224-3121; ask to speak
to your Senators.
E-MAIL—Use our Presby
Legislative Action Center (PLAC). If there is not an Urgent Alert highlighted
on this issue, you can go into PLAC and write your own email
message to your Members.
VISIT your Senators are home in district offices at various
times of the year. Get a group together and visit him or her
to talk about these concerns.
KEEP UP with news accounts of refugees in national stories
and through the PC(USA) Web site . World area associates and
the Disaster Relief Office in Louisville can answer questions
about specific situations and give you ideas for action (888)
728-7228 x5000 or (800) UP-2-DATE.
“Transformation of Churches and
Society Through Encounter with New Neighbors”
The 211th General Assembly (1999):
a. Reaffirm[s] the guiding theological and ethical principles
contained in the historical review of Presbyterian policy on
immigration and refugee issues, and commit to rediscover its
identity as a church of the stranger.
(1) Christians are obligated by the loving will of God to seek
to ensure that the basic needs of persons for food, clothes,
shelter and safety are met (Matt. 25-35-40).
(2) Christians believe in the intrinsic worth of each human
as a person made in the image of God.
(3) The Christian confession of Jesus Christ as Lord transforms “strangers” into
neighbors who are welcomed into our communities.
(4) Churches are called to ministry with refugees, asylum seekers,
and immigrants, and to public witness on their behalf.
(5) Christians have the responsibility to challenge and to
shape government policy regarding refugees, asylum seekers,
and immigrants.
(6) Love of neighbor requires Christians to seek justice for
refugees, asylum seekers, and immigrants.
(7) Faithfulness to Christ means Christians always live in
tension with national values/policies.
(8) Christians may affirm certain values in national and international
life as consistent with their theological vision of human community.
b. Reaffirm[s] the guiding policy principles contained in the
historical review of Presbyterian policy on immigration and
refugee issues and to utilize them to rediscover its identity
as a church of the stranger.
(1) Christians should engage in pastoral, compassionate, educational,
and prophetic ministries with refugees, asylum seekers, and
immigrants.
(2) The provision of sanctuary for asylum seekers may be an
appropriate moral response for churches even though the Untied
States government regards this witness as illegal. |