Across the
Presbyterian Church (USA) during 2005 and 2006, women and
men are being called to celebrate three special anniversaries
for women in religious leadership:
- In 1906, women in the United Presbyterian Church of North
America were admitted to ordination as deacons. 2006 marks
the 100th anniversary.
- In 1930, women in the Presbyterian Church in the U.S.A.
were admitted to ordination as ruling elders. A 75th anniversary
was celebrated in 2005.
- In 1955 the General Assembly of the PCUSA voted to approve
the ordination of women to the office of minister. It was
approved by the presbyteries, and in 1956 the first woman
was ordained in the tradition that is now the Presbyterian
Church (U.S.A.). Thus we celebrate in 2006 the 50th anniversary
of women ordained as ministers of the Word and Sacrament.
This
edition of Church & Society serves
as one of the ways chosen for celebrating these anniversaries
and honoring women's call to ordained ministry in the
Presbyterian Church (USA) and its predecessor denominations.
While some of the offerings in this issue reflect official
Presbyterian history, tradition and theology, others reflect
the lived experience, both the joy and the anguish, of persons
within the Presbyterian Church. Still others look to the future
and thus go beyond current General Assembly policy regarding
ordination. As with all issues of this journal, opinions expressed
are those of the authors. For the effort, frankness and courage
that lies behind each of these contributions, we give our thanks.
We begin this issue, as we always
must, with gratitude to God for creating us in the divine image,
redeeming us in sacrificial love, and sustaining us with an
abiding presence. God has always called women to ministry,
and women have always responded to that call. Thus, in Celebration,
we share Bettie Durrah's litany, "A Celebration
of the 50th Year of the Ordination of Clergywomen ...," which
gives thanks for the particular calling of women to the ministry
of the Word and Sacrament, while also honoring the wide variety
of forms women's ministry has taken, including the ministries
of women who served before their ordination was officially
recognized by church structures.
Our celebration is not complete,
however, unless we remember the years of labor that bring us
to this point. Fifty years, seventy-five years, even one hundred
years of recognition seem almost trivial when compared to the
centuries of exclusion. How and why did the majority of 20th
century Presbyterians draw a different conclusion about women's
ordination than our forebears? We address this question in
our section, Themes of the Debate.
How does the Reformed theological
tradition define ordination? How does ordination differ from
baptism? What are the "requirements" for ordination?
What difference does gender make? Aimee Moiso explores these
theological questions and their application to the debate over
women's ordination in "Order Semper
Reformanda."
The Bible, of course, stands
at the center of any decision made within the Reformed tradition;
it was and is often prooftexted to deny women's leadership.
How has the Bible been interpreted to support women's
ordination? How has our understanding changed over time? What
new methods of biblical scholarship inform our reading of ancient
texts? How does our approach to biblical interpretation affect
our understanding of the requirements for ordination? Aurelia
Fule brings a lifetime of scholarship to bear on these questions
in "Scripture and the Ordination of Women."
Scripture and theological integrity,
however, were not enough to achieve the full recognition of
women's call to ordained leadership. It took decades
of persistent advocacy to achieve what many now take for granted.
How was the ordination of women achieved through our Presbyterian
system of polity? What setbacks were experienced? What strategies
were implemented? What ultimately turned the tide? In "Breaking
Free From Silence: The Struggle for Women's Ordination
in the PCUSA," Jennifer Ashbaugh outlines the history
of the political process that led to the acceptance of women's
call to church office and the decisions we celebrate this year.
In some Presbyterian circles,
women's religious leadership has become so commonplace
that it is hard to imagine a time when it was categorically
denied. In other circles, women still struggle for recognition
of their gifts and calling. And, as both Clergywomen's
Experiences in Ministry: Realities and Challenges, the 2003
report of the Advocacy Committee for Women's Concerns,
and the 2004 Women of Color Consultation point out, even where
women's leadership is accepted in theoretical terms,
the practical experience of women in ministry can be an ongoing
struggle. Thus our next sections focus on the lived experience
of women in ordained leadership. Giving voice to women who
have followed God's call in recent decades, it moves
from the awareness of When God Calls to the reality of Ministry
in the Midst of Resistance. A Cloud
of Witnesses share moments
of grace and hope in living out the call.
Even as we celebrate how far
we have come, however, we must also acknowledge that the debate
continues. This is the focus of our fourth section, Visions
For Tomorrow. Kelsey Rice shares the voices of young women
deacons, elders, ministers and soon-to-be ministers, who continue
to see challenges to women's leadership in the PCUSA.
Outside the fairly small U.S. Presbyterian circle, overt controversy
continues over the proper role for women in religious leadership;
in some places it is so widely discouraged that even the debate
barely exists. Even within the Reformed tradition around the
world, women struggle for official recognition of God's
call in their lives. In "Reclaiming the Church as Community," Patricia
Sheerattan-Bisnauth of the World Alliance of Reformed Churches
describes ongoing conversations within the global church.
Just as women's ordination
continues to be debated in Christian communities, we must acknowledge
the current ordination debates within our denomination. Does
a review of the debate over women's ordination shed any
light on the contemporary questions surrounding the ordination
of gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender church members? Are
there theological, biblical, and political parallels in these
debates? Jack Rogers offers his insights in "Culture
vs. Revelation; Women's Ordination and LGBT Ordination
as Parallel Struggles."
Recognizing our brokenness as
the Body of Christ, however, leads us back to humbleness before
God and gratitude for the grace merited by none of us. Through
this grace we have been called, women and men throughout the
ages, to bear witness to the creating, redeeming and sustaining
God we worship and serve.
We offer this volume to the church
in the hope that it will serve not only as a resource for this
year of celebration but also as a touchstone for thoughtful
reflection and decision making in the years ahead, as the church
continues to embrace the vision for God's reign within
this world. May it be so! |