Presbyterians rally to oppose Arizona-style immigration law in Kentucky

National, local leaders vow to help defeat proposed legislation

January 31, 2011


Kentucky Presbyterians are working with other faith and humanitarian groups to oppose a state immigration law patterned after the controversial measure adopted last year in Arizona.

On Feb. 8, a broad coalition of groups is holding a rally at the state capital — Frankfort — to mobilize opposition to the pending legislation, which has passed the State Senate but which appears doomed in the House of Representatives. The bill was introduced by State Senate President David Williams, a Republican who is running for governor next year. The Kentucky Senate is controlled by Republicans, the House by Democrats.

In condemning the Arizona statute as “unfairly targeting Hispanic Americans,” last summer’s 219th General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) voted by a better than two-to-one margin  to “refrain from holding national meetings in states where travel by immigrant Presbyterians or Presbyterians of color might subject them to harassment or racial profiling.”

In a Jan. 7 letter to the Kentucky State legislature, the Rev. Gradye Parsons, General Assembly stated clerk; and Linda Valentine, General Assembly Mission Council executive director, said that while the PC(USA) supports comprehensive immigration reform at the federal level, the proposed Kentucky legislation (SB6) “is counter to the Gospel of Jesus Christ” and “would have a chilling effect on the work and worship of churches and entire communities.”

They added that the General Assembly’s action would preclude PC(USA) meetings and gatherings in Kentucky.

PC(USA) congregations are also taking action. On Jan. 26, the session of Crescent Hill Presbyterian Church in Louisville adopted a resolution, saying it opposed SBC because it would:

  • violate the basic tenets of the Christian faith, loving neighbor and offering hospitality to the stranger;
  • discourage people from other lands from settling in Kentucky and affiliating with and enriching our congregations;
  • create a climate of suspicion toward anyone who might fit the “profile”;
  • place at risk church members and friends whose faith commitment calls them to reach out without question to serve all of God’s children;
  • prohibit church members from participating or sponsoring events in Louisville, according to our denomination’s General Assembly action of 2010;
  • incur additional expense on the already strained budgets of the state and local municipalities.

The Rev. Tony Aja, coordinator for Hispanic/Latino Ministries for Mid-Kentucky Presbytery, said that the bill would have far-reaching consequences for the church’s work and ability to build relationships.

“If passed, this legislation not only would create havoc and distrust in all our immigrant communities, documented or not, but it would also jeopardize the ability of church people to minister with our new neighbors and be true to the gospel’s imperatives,” he wrote in an e-mail.

The Kentucky Council of Churches — whose executive director is the Rev. Marian McClure, former director of Worldwide Ministries for the PC(USA) — has also come out in opposition to SBC, as have the state’s Catholic bishops.

The full text of the letter from Parsons and Valentine:

The national office of the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) has been located in Louisville, Kentucky since 1988. Upon moving to Louisville, we were welcomed and accepted as an important part of this community. It has been a tremendous honor to live and to do ministry in a city and state that shares our value that there is not room in the church or in the community for discrimination against any person.

While the denominational seat is located in Louisville, our local churches are spread across the state in rural communities like Hazard and Mayfield and in urban centers like Louisville and Lexington, as well as across the country. We strongly believe that wherever the church is located, it is the hands and body of Christ, called to minister to, and be a house of worship for all God's people. We are led by Presbyterians of all nationalities, genders, races, ages, and ethnicities who have been called to minister in their local community.

This call includes worship and social programs such as food pantries, community kitchens, English as a Second Language classes, and mentoring programs. We do not ask the immigration status of those with whom we worship or serve because we wish to live a community that sees past a person}s immigration status to see the face of God.

The Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) supports comprehensive immigration reform at the federal level, enforceable by federal authorities. However. We are concerned about the recent proposed legislation, SB6. This legislation is counter to the Gospel of Jesus Christ and puts at risk not only members of our congregations but the people of the communities in which they serve.

If adopted, SB6 would have a chilling effect on the work and worship of churches and entire communities. Local police departments would divert resources to these civil immigration violations rather than focusing on keeping communities safe. The perception of the police among immigrant communities would fundamentally shift, creating an environment of fear where crime would go unreported and victims unassisted.

While it is a joy for us to share this city and state with Presbyterians from around the world, if SB6 is adopted, we would no longer be able to host our national meetings in Kentucky. In a single year, our offices host over 100 meetings resulting in thousands of people traveling to Louisville, staying in area hotels and eating in local restaurants.

However, our commitment to justice, fairness, and solidarity with those persecuted by unfair laws led our 2010 General Assembly to adopt a resolution that calls us to refrain from holding national meetings in states where laws exist that might subject our guests to harassment or intimidation.

Louisville has hosted our biennial General Assembly meeting (3,000 attendees), our triennial Presbyterian Women's Gathering (5,000) and many other Presbyterian Conferences. If SB6 becomes law, Louisville could no longer be considered as a venue for these events. This would undoubtedly negatively impact Kentucky's economy, especially in the Louisville area.

SB6 is harmful to all Kentuckians and our guests, especially as we work to create an atmosphere of acceptance and tolerance. We urge you consider the impact this proposed legislation would have on the people and economy of Kentucky and oppose this legislation.

  1. All of the state immigration laws mirror the federal law. Which law can we citizens choose not to follow? Or if you come here illegally, jumping the line over those who wait years to enter the US, are you more than a citizen? The PCUSA would do well to uphold American values of equal protection and responsibility under the law--which fortunately coincide with Biblical values-- rather than twisting Scripture to fit a secular, progressive, statist agenda.

    by Dana

    February 23, 2012

  2. "The Spirit of the Lord is upon us...."(LUKE 4:18-21) "For an unfair law is not a law at all"(St. Augustine). A fair law benefits our human race-women and men.The Bible does not say follow an unfair law. When you plant the self-hatred venom of a poisonous seed, you will cultivate rotten grapes."...he expected to yield grapes, but it yielded wild grapes." (ISAIAH 5:2). Justice is in action and peace is in reconciliation. Peace and blessings!

    by William Reyes

    February 23, 2011

  3. Just what is it about the proposed legislation that is "unfair"? The freedoms we all enjoy in the USA are dependent upon everyone obeying the laws. Those who choose which laws to obey do so at their peril.

    by Harold Anderson

    February 7, 2011

  4. I challenge the commentators to look around their Presbyteries and see which congregations are actually growing. They may be surprised to find that PC(USA) congregations which flourish are those same congregations that actively practice radical hospitality - to the immigrant (legal or not), to families of all types (straight or not), to the homeless, to former prisoners, to our elderly, etc.

    by Fritz

    February 5, 2011

  5. How else are you going to weed out the illegals. The Presbyterian Church is all ready walking on thin ice, with the gay's & your liberal ways. I am about ready to leave. Laws are laws obey them.

    by Donald Fultz

    February 4, 2011

  6. Arizona-style immigaration laws already exist in many states. The people who are proposing them now are late in getting involved in current events. The Kentucky effort is a non-event by know-nothings who encourage law breaking. They should know better. The PCUSA will lose more members by getting publicity on this issue. Attack the Obama Justice Department instead for suing Arizona for trying to enforce federal laws. If you want chaos, move to Egypt. Try being involved every day instead of when you think of a way to get the spotlight.

    by Bill Skinner

    February 4, 2011

  7. Will the last one out of the Presbyterian Church please turn out the lights, assuming there is any lights left on.

    by Jay Spooner

    February 1, 2011

  8. It's disturbing that Christian churches are getting involved in this issue. ......Laws benefit mankind, and the church would do more good by building schools, churches, and helping natives from within their own home countries. --- Father Patrick Bascio wrote in "On the Immorality of Illegal Immigration": "The Christian leadership of this country, not really comprehending the wide-ranging problems connected with illegal immigration, has blessed violating the sovereignty of our nation, depressing the wages of American workers, encouraging the growth of the most violent gangs in America, driven up black unemployment and draining the best and brightest of the Third World, leaving it helpless. How could the church possibly desire that this state of affairs continue?" ........

    by robbie

    February 1, 2011

  9. Dwyn Mounger, The PCUSA is only supporting a liberal world view.

    by Caleb Carter

    February 1, 2011

  10. I will make every attempt to do more business in Arizona and Kentucky now. The PC(USA) has proven over and over again to be a law of themselves, doing only what is right in their own eyes. Thank you for letting me know of this. I support the state.

    by Calvin

    February 1, 2011

  11. They should not oppose it, they should support it. We don't have a problem with them coming over here, they just need to do it legally! The Bible says to follow the law.

    by Caleb Carter

    February 1, 2011

  12. Many thanks, Gradye, Linda, and the session of Crescent Hill Church for your witness to the gospel in opposing this proposed law in Kentucky! You stand in the best tradition of the Synod of Barmen and the Belhar Confession. God bless you for your courageous and prophetic leadership of our branch of the Reformed heritage. Dwyn Mounger, Knoxville, in your neighboring state of Tennessee

    by Dwyn Mounger

    January 31, 2011